As the calendar turned to 2025, the dynamics of the stock market began to show distinct changes, with a noticeable divergence in the performance of individual stocksThis shift has allowed a larger number of stocks to outperform the S&P 500 index, providing investors, particularly stock pickers eager to surpass benchmark returns, with an expanded array of opportunitiesThe early indicators of this trend suggest a move away from the market's recent heavy dependence on a handful of mega-cap technology stocks that previously dominated the landscape.

As of last Friday, the S&P 500 index saw a modest increase of 2.4% year-to-date, but a staggering 49% of its constituent stocks had outperformed this benchmarkShould this pattern continue, it would signal the broadest market participation since 2022. In contrast, during the years 2023 and 2024, fewer than 30% of S&P 500 component stocks managed to exceed the index's performance, as the rally was primarily propelled by a small group of massive tech firms, most notably NvidiaThis trend of concentrated market gains hasn’t been seen since the late 1990s, specifically in 1998 and 1999.

This emerging divergence could indicate a pivotal moment for actively managed funds, especially as options traders anticipate increased variabilities in the performance of individual stocksFinancial experts have echoed this sentiment, suggesting that rising differentiation in stock performance is a promising sign for active management strategiesBen McMillan, Chief Investment Officer at IDX Advisors, suggested, “The increase in market divergence is great news for active management,” hinting at a potential renaissance for active investment strategies.

Recently, the Chicago Board Options Exchange's stock dispersion index has been trending upwards, striking a three-year high at the end of JanuaryTypically, this index tends to decline during earnings seasons; however, in recent weeks, it has defied expectations by continuing to rise.

The reasons behind this renewed volatility and stock variation are multifaceted:

Firstly, improvements in corporate profits might be contributing to a more widely distributed growth forecast for the fourth quarter of 2024, moving beyond the previous overreliance on the so-called 'magnificent seven' tech giants

Advertisements

This trend appears to be materializing, thereby decreasing the extreme concentration previously noted in the marketplace.

Secondly, numerous uncertainties within both the economy and the market have resulted in investor trepidation regarding the risks associated with the potential U.S. policy agenda and whether businesses' substantial investments in artificial intelligence infrastructure are prudent decisionsAdditionally, questions persist regarding the robustness of the U.S. economic fundamentals.

Furthermore, the uncertainties related to AI, tariffs, and macroeconomic outlook have generated heightened stock volatility, with Mandy Xu, head of derivatives intelligence at Cboe, articulating that even post-earnings season, individual stock volatility remains elevated, largely influenced by AI investments, tariff policies, and economic scenarios.

Over the past two years, actively managed funds have struggled to perform, especially amidst market conditions characterized by high concentration levelsData from S&P Dow Jones Indices suggests that fund managers face considerable challenges if they haven't markedly invested in the 'magnificent seven' stocks or momentum stocks like Palantir or VistraThe implication is that without heavy exposure to those stocks, underperformance relative to the S&P 500 is almost inevitable.

Heading into the first half of 2024, the prospects remain daunting for actively managed funds that invest in U.S. and global equitiesAnu Ganti, managing director of U.S. index investment strategy at S&P Dow Jones Indices, commented that the first half of 2024 is likely to be recorded in history as a particularly challenging time for the active management sector.

Notably, there's a discernible shift in market styles occurringOnce-overvalued sectors, such as information technology, have displayed lackluster performance, while undervalued sectors such as consumer staples, financials, and healthcare have gained traction in early 2025.

Among the 'magnificent seven', most companies have experienced subdued performance since the beginning of 2025, with Meta being the lone exception, enjoying substantial stock price increases at the year's start

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements