The U.S. stock market experienced a notable jolt on Friday, when the S&P 500 index fell more than 1%, disrupting the otherwise steady progress that had characterized the previous monthsThis drop was particularly jarring because it came after a period of remarkable stability in the market, leading to a reassessment of strategies that had been successful in a market that many had begun to believe was impervious to major correctionsFor some investors, the unexpected downturn raised questions about whether their tried-and-true tactics—such as buying the dips—could still offer the same returns in the face of evolving economic pressures.

Over the past several weeks, the S&P 500 had been on an upward trajectory, free from the large-scale drops that had typified much of 2024. The index had gone 35 consecutive trading days without experiencing a decline of more than 1%, an unprecedented stretch of calm in a year that had seen its fair share of volatilityMany market participants, lulled by this apparent serenity, began to believe that the markets had entered a period of unshakable growthThe consistent rises gave the impression of an unstoppable bull market, one where risks seemed distant and the path ahead appeared relatively clear.

Yet, despite the seeming tranquility, underlying risks had quietly been accumulating beneath the surface, ready to disrupt the complacencyThe most pressing concern was the possibility of escalating tariffs between the U.S. and its major trading partnersA trade war, it was feared, could reignite inflationary pressures and put additional strain on corporate profit marginsNormally, such an environment would prompt market caution, but the persistent bullish sentiment in the market meant that many remained optimistic, even as these uncertainties loomedIn fact, just days before the market downturn, the S&P 500 had posted two record highs, a sign that investors were still relatively unfazed by the looming risks.

Dan Greenhaus, Chief Strategist at Solus Alternative Asset Management, weighed in on this curious investor psychology

Advertisements

Greenhaus observed that investors were hesitant to act decisively, choosing instead to wait for tangible signs of how tariff issues would unfold. "Most investors seem to be standing pat, waiting for tangible tariff developments before considering the worst-case scenario," he noted. "I suspect many remain skeptical about the worst predictions." This skepticism toward alarmist forecasts reflects a broader belief in the resilience of the U.S. economy and its ability to weather external pressuresHowever, as the market showed on Friday, this cautious optimism can quickly unravel when the economic data fails to meet expectations.

From a more structural standpoint, the underlying volatility of the market was more apparent than it seemed on the surfaceKevin Gordon, Senior Investment Strategist at Charles Schwab, highlighted a concerning trend within the S&P 500. Despite the overall index showing upward momentum, the individual performance of its constituent stocks told a different storyGordon pointed out that the average decline among S&P 500 companies had reached 9% in 2025, a stark contrast to the previous year when the index saw no declines larger than 8.5%. This gap between the broad index and the performance of individual stocks underscores the increasing volatility within the marketFor Gordon, the current market dynamics suggest that the peaceful market of 2024 is unlikely to continue, given the geopolitical and economic tensions at play.

The catalyst for Friday's sell-off was the release of economic data that came in well below expectationsThe disappointing numbers, coupled with rising inflationary expectations among consumers, fueled the anxiety that had been simmering in the backgroundThese two factors combined to create a perfect storm of uncertainty, undermining investor confidence and leading to a sharp downturn in the S&P 500. In such an environment, traders were forced to reassess their positions, with many questioning whether the market had become too complacent in its bullish outlook.

However, even amid such economic anxiety, there was still a sense of cautious optimism in some quarters

Advertisements

The earnings reports of major U.S. corporations for the fourth quarter were notably strong, which provided some reassurance to the marketMoreover, traders were pinning their hopes on the potential for tax cuts and deregulation plans from the White House to provide a fresh boost to the economyIf these policies were to come to fruition, they could fuel stock valuations and potentially spark another rally in the marketThis type of optimism is consistent with the enduring "buy the dip" mentality that has defined investor behavior in recent years.

The concept of "buying the dip" has been a recurring theme in the market, and some investors still see it as the path forwardTanvir Sandhu, Chief Global Derivatives Strategist at Bloomberg Intelligence, echoed this sentiment, noting that while market pullbacks are inevitable, the strong earnings reports suggest that the broader market is not in a phase of widespread sell-offs. "As long as earnings remain strong, we might experience pullbacks and declines, but we are not in a phase of widespread sell-offs," Sandhu explainedThis view was also shared by Venu Krishna, Head of U.SEquity Strategy at Barclays, who observed a "strong tendency towards ‘buying the dip’" in the marketThis willingness to take advantage of market setbacks has been a key feature of the post-2020 market recovery, and many traders continue to believe that it offers an attractive opportunity for long-term growth.

Tom Lee, the founder of Fundstrat Capital and a prominent market bull, has remained particularly optimistic about the outlook for 2025. Lee believes that the market is likely to continue its upward trajectory, despite the occasional pullbacksHe remains confident that whenever the market shows signs of fatigue, the dips will be bought up quickly, continuing a pattern that has prevailed over the last several years. "Whenever the market shows any apparent signs of tiredness, these pullbacks get bought up, and I suspect this downturn will see similar behavior," Lee remarked

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements